Why the Church Must Be Intolerant

Public Domain, Wikipedia

Every community, inevitably, has a value or set of values that it considers fundamental, some basic good which positions every other claim to goodness.

For most of the modern liberal democracies, for example, freedom and equality play this determining role in the moral discourse. In Communist societies, economic justice, construed as the elimination of the class structure, would provide such a foundation. In the context of German National Socialism, the defense of the Fatherland and the will of the Führer anchored the moral system, however corrupt.

There is a rather simple means of identifying this ultimate value: in regard to any particular moral or political act, keep asking the question, “Why is this being done?” until you come to the point where you find yourself saying, “Well, because that’s just a good thing.” The “just a good thing” is the value that your society or culture considers non-negotiable and which in turn determines all subordinate values.

As a liberal society, ours has been, as I stated above, largely shaped by the values of liberty and equality, but in recent years, the ground has shifted a bit. Even a casual survey of the contemporary cultural scene reveals that the non-negotiables, the values undetermined and all-determining, seem to be inclusivity, tolerance, and diversity. If you asked most people today, especially the young, why should you be inclusive, tolerant, and accepting of diversity, the answer, I imagine, would be a puzzled, “Well, those are just good things to be.”

And here I would like to draw a contrast with the community of the Church. Within a properly Christian context, the ultimate value, which positions and determines any other value is neither tolerance, nor diversity, nor inclusivity, but rather love. I’ll admit that things can get confusing at this point, for the fundamental goods of the secular society today do have much in common with love, which is indeed often inclusive, tolerant, and encouraging of diversity. But not always—and thereupon hangs a tale.

To love is to will the good of the other as other. It is to break out of the black hole of one’s own self-regard and truly desire what is best for another. Therefore, to be sure, love is inclusive in the measure that it recognizes the essential dignity of each individual; love is tolerant, inasmuch as it respects the goodness of even those who hold errant points of view; and love encourages diversity, to the degree that it eschews the imperialistic imposition of one’s own ego upon another. However, sometimes love is exclusive, intolerant, and unaccepting of diversity—precisely because it wills the good of the other.

To illustrate this counter-intuitive proposition, let me begin with a rather ordinary example. Suppose you are the coach of a college baseball team, and you are presiding over tryouts. You survey a number of players of varying skill levels, and you are compelled to make your selection of, say, twenty players out of a hundred candidates. Your choices will exclude far more than they include; they will sow unhappiness more abundantly than joy.

But if you are a good man, they will be done out of love. You will be willing the good of those advanced players who can and should practice their skills through heightened competition and who will delight the fans who will attend their games; and you will be willing the good of those less advanced players who should not be permitted to compromise the integrity of the team and who should probably enter into some other arena of endeavor. In a word, both inclusion and exclusion will be acts of love, which proves that love is a more fundamental and positioning value.

Now a somewhat more elevated example. The Church of Jesus Christ is radically inclusive, for its ultimate purpose is to draw all people to the Lord. The Bernini Colonnade in St. Peter’s Square, reaching out like arms to embrace the massive crowds, is evocative of this aspiration. Jesus said, “Go and teach all nations,” and “declare the Gospel to the ends of the earth.” Thus, inclusivity is without doubt one of the dimensions of the Church’s love.

However, the Church is also exclusive and intolerant, for it discerns that certain forms of behavior are repugnant to its own integrity. Thus, for a variety of reasons, it excludes people from receiving communion, and in extreme cases, it formally excommunicates others. It solemnly declares that those who are in the state of mortal sin are not worthy to approach the Eucharistic table unless they first receive sacramental absolution.

And it unapologetically asserts that the Christian life has a formal structure, which by its very nature excludes certain styles of life that are incompatible with it. These discriminations, judgments, and exclusions are, if I might put it this way, modes of “tough love.” Though they seem harsh, they are ways of willing the good of the other.

A song that has been widely played in Catholic circles these past twenty years or so includes the line, “All are welcome in this place.” Cardinal Francis George once archly remarked, “Yes, all are welcome in the Church, but on Christ’s terms, not their own.”

Real love both includes and excludes; real love is both tolerant and intolerant.

Originally posted on Word on Fire

[See also: A Priest Explains the Hard Truth About Why the Church Is In Decline]

[See also: Where God Died & Rose Again: Inside the Ancient Church of the Holy Sepulchre]




  1. You could certainly see your skills within the paintings you write. The arena hopes for more passionate writers such as you who are not afraid to mention how they believe. At all times follow your heart.

  2. I actually arrived right here from a different website about garageband for windows and considered I might as well look at this. I enjoy the things I see so I am just following you. Looking towards checking out the blog again.

  3. Thanks for writing this, I saved this website. I’m furthermore struggling to find information on upvc window manufacturers, are you aware the place where I might find one thing such as that? I will return quickly!

  4. My coder is trying to persuade me to move to .net from PHP. I have always disliked the idea because of the costs. But he’s tryiong none the less. I’ve been using Movable-type on various websites for about a year and am anxious about switching to another platform. I have heard fantastic things about blogengine.net. Is there a way I can import all my wordpress content into it? Any kind of help would be really appreciated!

  5. Magnificent beat ! I would like to apprentice while you amend your web site, how could i subscribe for a blog web site? The account aided me a acceptable deal. I have been tiny bit acquainted of this your broadcast offered bright clear concept

  6. I was talking to a good friend of my own about this info and also about Arvind Pandit too. I feel you made a number of very good points in this article, we’re also excited to find out more material from you.

  7. Good web site! I really love how it is easy on my eyes and the data are well written. I am wondering how I could be notified when a new post has been made. I’ve subscribed to your feed which must do the trick! Have a nice day!

  8. Greetings! This is my very first comment here so I just wanted to say a fast hello and tell you I really enjoy reading through your posts. Can you suggest other blogs that go over vshare download? I’m as well highly curious about that! Many thanks!

  9. Appreciating the persistence you put into the blog and in-depth material you present. It is amazing to come across a website from time to time that isn’t the similar outdated rehashed content. Amazing read! I’ve saved your blog and I’m including the RSS feeds to my kik for pc website.

  10. Hi there, you’re certainly correct. I frequently look over your articles thoroughly. I’m furthermore interested in gaming headphones, you could write about this from time to time. Good day.

  11. Admiring the time and energy you invested in the website and in depth information you offer. It really is awesome to find a site occasionally that is not the same out of date re-written stuff. Excellent read! I’ve saved your blog and I’m adding the RSS feeds to our real estate rentals web page.

  12. of course like your web site but you need to check the spelling on several of your posts. Several of them are rife with spelling issues and I find it very bothersome to tell the truth nevertheless I’ll surely come back again.

  13. I felt amazing to read this article and I think you are really right. Tell me if you’re considering free facetime, that’s my main competency. I really hope to check back with you soon enough, bye for now!

  14. Hey there can you tell me which blog platform you are utilizing? I’m planning to do my very own blog on more twitter followers in the near future although I am having a difficult time making the decision.

  15. Our LGV (Large Goods Vehicle) HGV training is based in East London, and our LGV/ HGV courses are taught by qualified DVSA LGV & HGV trainers. LGV was formerly known as HGV, where it used to be referred to as HGV Class 2 (now called LGV Category C) and HGV class 1 (Now called LGV Category C+E).

  16. Thank you for the marvelous posting! I really liked learning about.I will remember to bookmark your website and definitely will come back in the future. I wish to suggest that you keep on with the fine work, maybe try to think of free new movies online too, have a fine morning!

  17. My partner and I really like your blog and find almost all of your articles to be just what I am looking for. Would you offer other people to post content material for you? I would not mind creating an article relating to personal injury lawyer or maybe on many of the things you’re writing about on this site. Cool place!

  18. I was discussing with a friend of mine regarding this article and even about arcade games too. I believe you made a number of great points here, we’re looking forward to keep reading material from you.

  19. Does your site have a contact page? I’m having trouble locating it but, I’d like to send you an e-mail. I’ve got some creative ideas for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great blog and I look forward to seeing it develop over time.

  20. Thank you so much for discussing the idea, I saved this web page. I am furthermore in search of guidance about cosmetic dentistry, are you aware exactly where I can discover a thing such as that? I’ll be back in a little while!

  21. I’m really loving the design of your site. Do you ever face any kind of browser compatibility situations? A few of my own blog visitors have lamented concerning my free full movies blog not working effectively in Explorer but appears fantastic in Chrome. Are there any tips to help repair this matter?

  22. Thank you, I have just been looking for information approximately this subject for a long time and yours is the best I’ve came upon till now. But, what in regards to the conclusion? Are you certain about the supply?|

  23. Great post. I used to be checking constantly this weblog and I’m inspired! Extremely helpful info specifically the closing section :) I deal with such information a lot. I was seeking this particular information for a very lengthy time. Thanks and good luck. |

  24. Amazing blog! Do you have any tips and hints for aspiring writers? I’m hoping to start my own website soon but I’m a little lost on everything. Would you advise starting with a free platform like WordPress or go for a paid option? There are so many options out there that I’m completely confused .. Any recommendations? Bless you!

Leave a Reply