What Bothered Me About President Obama’s Christmas Remarks

The White House, YouTube

Just a few weeks ago, at a ceremony for the lighting of the national Christmas tree, President Obama remarked on the meaning of the season. Here are some of the things he said:

“Over these next few weeks, as we celebrate the birth of our Savior, as we retell the story of weary travelers, a star, shepherds, Magi, I hope that we also focus ourselves on the message that this child brought to this Earth some 2,000 years ago—a message that says we have to be our brother’s keepers, our sister’s keepers; that we have to reach out to each other, to forgive each other. To let the light of our good deeds shine for all. To care for the sick, and the hungry, and the downtrodden.

“And of course, to love one another, even our enemies, and treat one another the way we would want to be treated ourselves. It’s a message that grounds not just my family’s Christian faith but that of Jewish Americans, Muslim Americans, non-believers—Americans of all backgrounds.”

Now in a way, there is nothing whatsoever wrong with these ideas and sentiments. Who could possibly be against treating others with respect, offering forgiveness for offenses, and caring for those in need? And I certainly don’t blame President Obama for making these remarks. Both Democrat and Republican presidents, in their capacity as chief magistrates of the civil religion, have expressed similar convictions for many years.

What does bother me, however, is reducing Christmas to a level so low, so banal, that the great Christian feast is offensive to precisely no one.

If President Obama is right, even those who profess no belief in God should welcome Christmas with nothing but enthusiasm! But this sort of reductionism is, in fact, directly repugnant to a feast which, in its essence, is revolutionary, subversive, and, if properly understood, offensive to just about everyone.

What could I possibly mean? Well, if we take an honest look at the Biblical texts dealing with Christmas, we will find that they have precious little to do with sentimentality, or the embracing of a common morality, or the cultivation of a “let’s all get along” attitude.

In the second chapter of Matthew’s Gospel, we read of the visit of the Magi, astrologers from “the east,” probably from Babylon where a quasi-scientific star-gazing discipline was cultivated. They let it be known that they were in search of “the newborn king of the Jews,” whose star they had observed at its rising.

When this news was spread about, was it met with delight, enthusiasm, excitement, and sentimental feelings? Hardly. Listen to what Matthew tells us: “When King Herod heard this, he was greatly troubled, and all Jerusalem with him.”

Why would the arrival of a tiny baby, who would grow up to bear a message of love, have excited such negativity? We must remember that the child is described as a king, which means someone who comes to rule; more precisely, he is characterized as king of the Jews, and this was the very title that Herod claimed. Therefore, Herod, quite correctly, saw him as a threat to his prerogatives and position.

But why would the entire capital be in an uproar? We must recall what the Bible consistently says about cities, that is, the way we human beings typically organize ourselves politically, socially, and culturally. Cain, the murderer of Abel, is the founder of cities; Babel, full of arrogance and imperialistic designs, is seen as a typical city; and Jesus himself implied that the devil controls all the cities of the world. The trembling of all of Jerusalem at the birth of the baby king is a function of the demand that that king will eventually make, the change that his rule will affect.

Just to drive this point home, Matthew tells us that Herod, having been duped by the Magi, furiously lashed out, ordering the murder of every boy in Bethlehem under two years of age. Not exactly the reaction of someone who is just delighted that the Christmas season has arrived!

If we examine Luke’s account of the birth of Jesus, we find very similar motifs. Luke sets up his story as the tale of two rival Emperors: Caesar, the king of the world, and Jesus, the baby king. While Caesar rules from his palace in Rome, Jesus has no place to lay his head; while Caesar exercises rangy power, Jesus is wrapped in swaddling clothes; while Caesar surrounds himself with wealthy and sophisticated courtiers, Jesus is surrounded by animals and shepherds of the field.

And yet, the baby king is more powerful than Augustus—which is signaled by the presence of an army (stratias in the Greek) of angels in the skies over Bethlehem. All four of the Gospels play out as a struggle, culminating in the deadly business of the cross, between the worldly powers and the power of Christ.

For Jesus is not simply a kindly prophet with a gentle message of forgiveness; he is God coming in person to assume command. He is the Lord. And the entire New Testament couldn’t be clearer that his Lordship means that all those who follow a contrary rule—meaning, pretty much every one of us—are under judgment.

To be sure, the distinctive mark of Jesus’ Lordship is love, compassion, forgiveness, and non-violence—but this is not the stuff of sentimentality and warm feelings. It is a provocation, a challenge, a call to conversion of the most radical kind.

Here’s a video of President Obama’s remarks (the part quoted above starts at 7:26):

What do you think of Bp. Robert Barron’s take on President Obama’s remarks? Let us know in the comments!

Originally published on Word on Fire




  1. Hello, I think your website might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your blog site in Ie, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, awesome blog!

  2. Very good blog you have here but I was wondering if you knew of any forums that cover the same topics talked about in this article? I’d really like to be a part of online community where I can get feed-back from other experienced people that share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Many thanks!

  3. Appreciating the persistence you invested in the website and in depth info you provide. It is wonderful to come across a site every now and then which is not the similar obsolete rehashed stuff. Amazing read! We’ve saved your website and I am including your RSS feeds to my Arvind Pandit Kansas web page.

  4. Many thanks for this great write-up! I really appreciated it.I’ll make certain to take note of the website and definitely will come back later on. I want to encourage you to definitely keep on with the good job, maybe write about free facetime app as well, have a fantastic afternoon!

  5. It was wonderful to read this info and I believe you’re entirely right. Inform me in the event that you are curious about facetime for android, that’s my main competency. I hope to hear from you in the near future, take good care!

  6. I personally arrived over here from another page about online marketing jobs and considered I should read this. I adore the things I see so now I”m following you. Getting excited about looking into the site all over again.

  7. My spouse and I totally like your site and find a majority of the blog posts to be what precisely I’m in need of. Would you offer people to post material for you? I would not mind producing a story on international real estate or maybe on a lot of the things you are writing about here. Again, awesome information site!

  8. I actually arrived right here via some other web address about intercom system installation and imagined I may as well look into this. I adore the things I see thus now I”m following you. Getting excited about looking into your website back again.

  9. Heya i’m for the first time here. I came across this board and I find It really useful & it helped me out much. I hope to give something back and aid others like you aided me.

  10. I was speaking to a buddy of mine around this article and even about android facetime app too. I do think you made a number of great points in this case, we’re excited to read more stuff from you.

  11. Our LGV (Large Goods Vehicle) HGV training is based in East London, and our LGV/ HGV courses are taught by qualified DVSA LGV & HGV trainers. LGV was formerly known as HGV, where it used to be referred to as HGV Class 2 (now called LGV Category C) and HGV class 1 (Now called LGV Category C+E).

  12. You are absolutely right, I’d love to discover more information on this particular subject! I’m as well interested by tv series online because I consider it really is quite trendy lately. Thanks!

  13. It was actually wonderful reading this info and I feel you’re completely correct. Tell me in the event that you’re involved in personal injury firms, that is my major expertise. Hope to see you soon enough, bye for now!

  14. Greetings, I am really thrilled I discovered this web page, I actually encountered you by accident, when I was looking on Digg for pokemon go game. Anyways I am here now and would simply enjoy to say thank you for a fantastic write-up and the all-round interesting website (I furthermore love the design), I don’t have the time to look over it all at the minute but I have book-marked it and also added the RSS feeds, so when I have sufficient time I’ll be returning to look over a great deal more. Please do maintain the amazing job.

  15. Hello there I am so excited I found out your webpage, I basically discovered you by mistake, when I was looking on Yahoo for home heating systems. Anyways I’m here now and would really like to say thanks a lot for a marvelous article and the all-round entertaining site (I too enjoy the theme), I don’t have enough time to read through it entirely at the moment but I have bookmarked it and even added the RSS feed, so whenever I have sufficient time I’ll be back to browse much more. Please do maintain the wonderful work.

  16. We unquestionably enjoy your website and find nearly all of your blogposts to be precisely what I am trying to find. Do you offer guest writers to post content material for you? I would not mind publishing a piece of text regarding sea freight services or even on most of the subjects you’re writing about on this website. Great information site!

  17. Admiring the persistence you put into this site and comprehensive material you provide. It really is awesome to discover a blogging site every now and then which isn’t the same old rehashed stuff. Awesome read! We’ve bookmarked your website and I am adding the RSS feeds to my fast shipping page.

Leave a Reply